UniquePetsWiki is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read more

Water Dog Vs Axolotl

Which one is better, water dog vs axolotl? Water Dog and Axolotl are unique and impressive animals and can become beloved pets. They both belong to the salamander family.

Their typical features make them entertaining to watch for your family.

That said, each of them has unique needs and care requirements, and a lack of know-how on how to keep them will make you end up with regrets. 

Keep tuned in the article for more information about these fascinating animals: on their similarities, differences, and nuances in case you are thinking of buying and taking on either as a new pet. 

Water Dog Vs Axolotl

Identifying characteristics Water Dog Vs Axolotl
Identifying characteristics Water Dog Vs Axolotl
InformationWater DogAxolotl
SpeciesAmbystoma mavortium familyAmbystoma mexicanum family
OriginNorthern AmericaSouth America
Lifespan:25 years15 years.
Habitatin water and into terrestrial adults.Stay aquatic their entire lives.
matureMetamorphoseNon metamorphose
Color:darker in colorDiversity
Dietearthworms, crickets, freshly killed minnows, tadpoles, and glass (grass) shrimpanything else that can fit inside their mouth and swallow whole (worms, insects, small fish, etc.)
Availabilitywidespread throughout the U. Sextinct now, though, in the wild
Cost$30-$60$35-$70
Comparison of Water Dog vs Axolotl

Despite Water Dog and Axolotl coming from the larval forms of salamanders (where they share some similar characteristics), they have tonic differences in their personality, size, and other features.

For instance, Water Dog is a noisy animal and squeaks a lot and is solitary, while Axolotl is docile and calm animals and independent.  

Moreover, Water Dog is larger than Axolotl in size; its size varies from 8 – 18 inches in length, while Axolotl’s average size is 10 inches (from the nose tip up to the tail end).

Also read: Why Is My Axolotl Not Growing?

Overview: Origin, Appearance, and Color

Axolotl
Axolotl | Credit: Jesue92 / Canva.com

Water Dog is native to Northern America, where it lives in the United States and Canada.

At the same time, Axolotl is native to Lake Xochimilco and Lake Chalco in the valley of Mexico in South America.

Water Dog has spread throughout the United States while Axolotl is now extinct though it exists in the wild.

Water Dog appears bushy, has flat heads, stubby legs, broad tails, four distinct toes in their feet, red exterior gills, and he is so much darker in color and changes color when it metamorphoses.

While Axolotl, on the other hand, is known as walking Mexican fish. It has distinguishable features like, have short legs, cylindrical bodies, feathery gills, and a pretty long tail.

Also, it has four toes on its front feet, five toes on the back feet, and moveable eyelids. Axolotl is known for its largemouth, blunt snout, and impressive smile. 

In addition, Axolotl has four distinct/common colors, e.g., Albino (golden), Leucistic (pink), and Axanth (gray).

Metamorphose

Water Dog Metamorphose
Water Dog Metamorphose | Credit: Olympian Exotics / YouTube.com

What is a metamorphosis? As a new owner, you find the term new. Well, metamorphose simply means to undergo some form of transformation so that there is an entirely different appearance. 

In our case, Water Dog undergoes morphological changes while Axolotl spends all its entire life inside water.

The Water Dog body changes from larva to miniature adult replicate., usually from aquatic habitat to terrestrial habitat for the adult one.

Water Dogs are known to be false salamanders and have a long larval phase; however, they will metamorphose eventually. 

Water Dog starts his life in water and later develops readily into terrestrial adults. The changes usually occur around 12 to 18 months.

His gills to breathe in water will shrink, and his lungs will become wholly functional. As a result, he can move over to land-living and will only return inside water for mating.

On the other hand, Axolotl’s body does not transform and stays in water throughout his entire life. 

Care Requirements

Water Dog Metamorphose dark color
Water Dog Metamorphose dark color | Credit: Olympian Exotics / YouTube.com

Water Dog and Axolotl require special requirements and needs for you to rear them in your household. As a result, keeping and caring for Water Dog will be a very aberrant experience from keeping Axolotl. 

This is evident when Water Dog starts to metamorphose, and as an owner, you must be well equipped and prepared for these changes. Let us look at specific requirements Water Dog and Axolotl will need.

Also read: Full Requirements & Water Conditions for Axolotl in Captivity

House

To keep a Water Dog, you must have two different homes, starting with an aquarium and ending up with a terrarium immediately it develops into terrestrial salamanders. 

The best tank size should be around 15 – 20 gallons; this will provide sufficient space for him to roam around. During the start of morphological changes, he will gravitate toward the surface to breathe.

You should reduce the water level during this time and provide a platform for him to get access should he desire to do so. After completion of the process, you put him into a waterless terrarium.

On the other hand, Axolotl requires only a suitable and stable aquarium for the rest of his life. Likely, it also requires sufficient space to roam; hence, the tank size of 20 gallons is worthwhile.

You should routinely change the water in the tanks for Water Dog and Axolotl or clean them using a filter.

Do not always handle or touch both of them for whatsoever reasons unless changing waters or taking them to the vet.

crapelles Reptile Terrarium Glass Box Large Metal Ventilation net Door for Reptile Amphibians

crapelles Reptile Terrarium Glass Box Large Metal Ventilation net Door for Reptile Amphibians Insect Waterproof Ventilation Transparency Clearly Visible Inside Advanced Feeder
  • 1. Glass terrarium for reptiles, amphibians, insect, fish or plant.
  • 2. Waterproof,every terrarium is tested for leaks.
  • 3. Top window ventilation,safe lock prevent escape, a feeding hole.
  • 4. Single-door for 360° viewing, Waterproof,Moisturizing.
  • 5. Size 15.7×11×9 inches, Volume 6 gallon US (23 L) .Perfect for your desk. Pet allways accompany you.

Last update on 2022-11-28 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Temperature

While still in the aquatic habitat, the optimum water temperature for Water Dog should vary from 600 to 700 Fahrenheit. In contrast, Axolotl pets require an optimum temperature of 600 to 650 Fahrenheit.

Also read: Axolotl Temperature (Tips to Maintain an Ideal Temperature)

Costs

Buying a Water Dog is relatively cheaper than Axolotl; for instance, the Water Dog price ranges from $30-$60 while Axolotl price range is $35-$70 from your local pet breeder around you. 

To keep and own both of them, you will incur additional costs for delivery fees, setting up tanks, food, and vet, and recurring costs. 

It will cost you around $100 – $300 on average to set up an enclosure for either Water Dog or Axolotl. However, for Water Dog, you will need to set aside additional cash for terrestrial habitat. 

Recurring costs are vet and food, which will cost around $100 since both require a constant check-up to ensure suitable conditions of their surroundings. 

Can You Keep a Water Dog and Axolotl Together?

Water Dog and Axolotl can live together in one tank, but it’s inadvisable to keep them together. That is simply due to an array of reasons since each has its behavior and temperament.

For instance, Water Dog and Axolotl can be aggressive to each other for food, pecking order, and another important reason for keeping them separate is the morphological process in Water Dogs; hence both thrive well when kept in separate tanks.

Even though Water Dogs are solitary animals and the best tank mates are males versus females or young versus adults.

In contrast, for Axolotl, the tank mates are Guppy Fish, Zebra Danios, Apple Snails, and other axolotls, especially adults. 

Also read: Can Axolotls Live Together?

PINVNBY Resin Reptile Platform Artificial Tree Trunk Reptile Tank Decor

PINVNBY Resin Reptile Platform Artificial Tree Trunk Reptile Tank Decor Food Water Dish Bowl for Bearded Dragon,Lizard, Gecko, Water Frog,Snake
  • Made of premium resin and Eco-friendly material, non-toxic, pollution-free, completely safe for aquatic life.
  • Lifelike rock desing, provide a natural environment for your reptiles.decorate and maintenance your aquarium
  • Designed with flat bottom, stand in your water tank or aquarium easily and steadily.
  • Well design with shallow bottom, making it easier for your pet to eat.
  • Size of 7.1 x 6.3 x 3.9 inch Suitable for small size reptiles, like bearded dragon,tortoise, lizard,snake, frog, gecko or other reptiles.

Last update on 2022-11-27 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

FAQs

Are axolotls called water dogs?

No. Axolotls are typical salamanders native to Lake Xochimilco and Lake Chalco in the valley of Mexico in South America.

Do water dogs turn into salamanders?

Water Dogs are false salamanders that metamorphose into land-dwelling terrestrial tiger salamanders in the right conditions. 

What is the difference between mudpuppies and an axolotl?

An Axolotl spends its entire life in an aquatic aquarium, and it’s known to regrow its body parts but do not metamorphose. At the same time, a mudpuppy has aquatic and terrestrial habitat and metamorphose. 

Can Mudpuppies and axolotls live together?

No. Since each has its behavior and temperament, they will be aggressive to each other; as a result, they thrive well when you keep them in separate tanks. 

What are baby axolotls called?

Baby Axolotls are called Larvae. They originate from slime-covered eggs and take about two weeks to be hatched. Hence, considered part of the salamander family. 

Final Words

To sum up, Water Dogs and Axolotls are unique and amazing creatures that are fun to watch and keep in your household. As a result, keeping and owning them as pets is a great privilege. 

Before owning a water Dog or axolotl, you need to consider their requirements, care, and needs. This will also depend on your tastes, preferences, space, and pocket worth. 

To be on the safer side, you should have close contact with your vet or pet breeder, who will advise you accordingly and give you the genealogy of each of them. And get guidance on how to maintain them.

About UniquePetsWiki

UniquePetsWiki is the preferred educational source on pets favored by experienced herptologists and new owners alike. With hundreds of articles on everything pertaining to pets including reptiles, squirrels, and other pets, our experienced team provides reliable and accurate content you can trust.

From proper husbandry and habitat guidance, to articles on health concerns, diet, and extensive care guides, UniquePetsWiki is here to educate everyone on all pets concerns.

Disclaimer

UniquePetsWiki is not a veterinary website, nor should any of the reptile health information on our site replace the advice of a certified veterinary professional. If your pet is experiencing a medical emergency, contact an experienced veterinarian immediately.

UniquePetsWiki is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.